Showing posts with label Victor Dubin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Victor Dubin. Show all posts

Wednesday, 5 December 2018

DON'T PANIC. Practice Upashama (Calm)

by Victor
If you haven’t yet read The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams, then I highly recommend you do. After you are done reading this article, do yourself a favor and go to your local library, local bookstore, or online source and pick up a copy. While the novel is an enjoyable existential romp through the galaxy, relevant to this blog it’s no big spoiler to tell you that the message of the book is “Don’t Panic.” This is not just the underlying message of the book, it’s explicitly stated, early and often and is sometimes even included on the front cover! “Don’t Panic” is a pretty good way of describing an approach to upashama, calm, considered one of the yamas of yoga practice. 

For many years I have considered upashama, calm, to be one of the yamas. I originally learned about upashama in Georg Feuerstein’s Encyclopedic Dictionary of Yoga (1990): 

“The Siddha-Siddhanta-Paddhati (II.32) speaks of calmness (upashama)…and makes the point that [this has] to be learned gradually.” 

However, when sitting down to write this series on additional yamas and niyamas not found in Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras, I attempted to follow up on Feuerstein’s citation, but could not find this specific reference. If any reader has documentation of the inclusion of upashama in yama practice, I would be interested to follow up on suggestions for further reading. While I would appreciate better documentation of historical reference, I do not doubt that Feuerstein included upashama in his description of yamas in good faith. I have included calm as a yama in my own practice and teaching of yoga for some time, so I can at least attest to its value from my own perspective as student and teacher. 

As a reminder to those who are familiar with and as an introduction for those who are new to my perspective on yama and niyama, I do not view them as states to be achieved, but rather as actions to be practiced. In this regard, upashama, calm, is no different. When they are encouraged to practice being calm, people sometimes assume that calm is a feeling that will be reached after some other action has been engaged. In this view, calm is a destination, something to strive for, an external thing that can be attained, an end. What I am suggesting is that calm, in the context of yoga, is a way of engaging, something to cultivate internally, a practice.

When you sit down to meditate your mind might have a tendency to wander, to perseverate on past problems, and imagine impending issues. Upashama is a practice of being okay with these tendencies of the mind, a practice of staying calm amidst the perceived tumult of consciousness. There is no value in self castigation. There is no value in magnifying the distractions of the mind by giving them more power. Instead, find the value in acceptance of your mind as it is, yourself as you are. Practice being calm, patiently watching the waves of thought arise and fall away. For many, this practice of calm amidst disorder has the effect of dissipating these disruptions, at least partially, if not completely. However, the practice of upashama is truly practiced without the reliance on these end results. You practice being calm even if the uproar in your mind increases rather than decreases. In so doing you are taking a longer-term approach, understanding that while there may be short-term distress, you are building a long-term skill of being able to be calm even when the circumstances are challenging at the deepest levels.

Of course, there are some practical actions you can take to build this skill of calm. Intentional breathing, pranayama, is a clear example and its benefits have been frequently discussed on this blog. Specifically relevant to why practicing breathing is upashama is Nina’s post Why Meditating on Your Breath Works. But there is also a fundamentally simple common experience that most of us have which best illustrates this point. Think of a time when you were just about to do something challenging, scary, nerve racking, potentially life changing, or even just exciting. Maybe you were about to give a public speech, go into an interview, say “I love you” to someone for the first time, or otherwise. What most of us do instinctively just before the action is to take a deep breath. No one had to tell us to do this, we didn’t learn it in school, but maybe we’ve seen others in our lives do it just before they do something that looks challenging. 

What does that deep breath do for you? How does it make you feel? For most of us, in that moment of breathing, everything else drops away. The thing we are about to do, the fear, the anxiety, the contemplation of potential outcome, the desire to run away, all of that fades, at least just for that instant, as we are completely focused on the one breath. Pranayama can simply be a way of extending that experience beyond a single breath and into a series of breaths, a way of practicing calm. 

Calm is also something we often practice in asana. Many of the postures are inherently challenging. They often agitate and intensify in the short term. But when we intentionally practice putting ourselves into challenging circumstances, like in the practice of many yoga postures, then just as intentionally practice calm amidst the challenge, we strengthen this skill. The Navy Seal Jocko Willink once described the way that Navy Seals have incorporated yoga into their training. He explained that often Navy Seals are in circumstances where parts of their nervous system are ringing alarm bells, telling them to fight or flee. However, most often, in order to assure their best chance at not only survival, but also success, the best course of action is the counterintuitive one, to remain calm. He explained that yoga posture practice was one way that he and his team train themselves to be calm at the edges of intensity and learn to watch the intensity ebb. You certainly do not have to be a Navy Seal to recognize the powerful tool that practicing upashama can be. When you practice calm while in the controlled environment of a yoga posture, you are training yourself to be able to better weather the inevitable storms and stresses of life more broadly. 

We are constantly being inundated with the message that we should not be calm. The news media, product pushers, the business world, and even our friends and family would often have us believe that we are and should constantly be in a state of crisis. There are certainly ways in which we might all work toward a more just and robust society and reduce unnecessary suffering in the world, but freaking out is not going to help. Neither will nihilism or gloom and doom. What will help amidst the chaos, so that you can better focus your mind and body on the important work at hand, is to be calm. It is most likely that this ability will manifest because you have been developing this important skill, when you sit, when you breathe, when you move, and when you face the inevitable challenges that confront us all. Find that upashama, like all of the yamas and niyamas is not simply a philosophical notion or imagined ideal, but a practical skill that you can practice and hone.


Subscribe to Yoga for Healthy Aging by Email ° Follow Yoga for Healthy Aging on Facebook and Twitter ° To order Yoga for Healthy Aging: A Guide to Lifelong Well-Being, go to Amazon, Shambhala, Indie Bound or your local bookstore.

Follow Victor Dubin on Facebook and @victordubin on Instagram, see Victor’s upcoming workshops and trainings, and view Victor’s online yoga class videos.

Wednesday, 5 September 2018

Cultivating Dana (Charity) as A Practice

by Victor
The Soup by Pablo Picasso
In November of 2015 Ram wrote an excellent post on dana, the niyama that includes generosity, altruism, and acts of giving. Dana: On the Positive Effects of Charity. Ram’s article does an excellent job of describing the what and why of dana. Today I will attempt to explain the how. 

Generosity, altruism, and acts of giving are practices that can be strengthened over the long term by making them as routine as sitting in meditation, breathing mindfully, and stretching your body in postures. In this vein, dana (generosity, altruism, and giving) is considered one of yoga’s niyamas. The Mahanarayana Upanishad describes dana this way: 

“All beings live on the gift of the other. Through gifts strangers become friends, they ward off difficulties. On gifts and giving, everything rests. That is why charity is the highest.” 

Creating consistent routines is essential to continued growth and development, whether you are interested in developing better balance, strengthening your core muscles, loosening your shoulders, or being more generous. Of course, it feels nice to go to one yoga class, one time, but as anyone who has practiced consistently over the long term can tell you, the benefits of consistency and longevity are many times greater. Likewise, as you practice giving more regularly and make it a long-term endeavor, you find that the individual acts of charity feel easier, freer, and more like a part of who you are. 

While this could easily devolve into a discussion of what you give and the quantities, I think it is useful to separate those considerations out from the acts of giving. In other words, each of us has different things and in differing amounts that we could give: money, time, energy, attention, care, access, etc. The niyama dana is not about comparative giving. Instead it is about self reflection and a recognition that the act of giving is a form of yoga practice. So, in this regard, there is no need to parse out quantities or percentages. More basically this is a practice of evaluating what you can give of yourself in each moment of being. 

Practicing dana can be as simple as turning the thought “what am I getting out of this?” into the thought “what more can I give to this?” An easy place to see this is in the perspective you bring to yoga asana practice. Sometimes we are prone to viewing the postures like pills. We think things like “what is this posture supposed to do for me?” We think and sometimes say this as if we are passively receiving the posture, as if we have no agency at all, as if it is not us who is the one creating the position with our own bodies! Once you make the mental switch from trying to get something from a posture and instead find more and more ways to give your energy to what it is that you are doing, suddenly the posture and you who are performing it come alive! In a real sense, it is that act of finding the energy, the strength, the space, the breath, you have to give that reveals the benefit of that practice. The more you practice engaging from this mental framework, the easier it becomes to drop into it. 

In my experience as a teacher, the primary reason that people struggle with this is not because they are inherently selfish, it is because they consistently under value how much they have to offer to the moment. It is not that people are holding back some degree of hip flexibility like a bio-mechanical hoarder. It is that they think that whatever degree of hip flexibility they do have access to is not enough. One great benefit of practicing dana, of being generous, of giving what you have to give in the moment, is that it reveals to you how much you had to give all along. You discover the degree of hip flexibility you do have. You illuminate how much compassion you do have. You highlight the great degree of safety and stability that you do have. You recognize how wealthy you really are. 

While dana is something you can practice regularly while doing yoga postures it is also useful to create other Dana practice opportunities. This practice is strengthened when you make it a regular part of your routine. I will give you a personal example, not because I think everyone should necessarily do what I do, but because it may highlight one way in which you might create a dana routine. Like many people I shop for groceries on a weekly basis. I am aware that there are many people who cannot have such a regular routine and who do not have access to food on a consistent basis. So, I downloaded the Share The Meal app, which is run by the World Food Program. The app gives me options to share one day of meals ($.50), one week of meals ($3.50), one month of meals ($15.00), and more. While it is possible to make a one-time donation to the World Food Program in a larger amount, I choose to donate money, which in turn buys meals, every time that I am at the grocery store. I don’t want to give and then forget about it. I want to make giving a part of my life. Again, the purpose of this example is not to self-aggrandize or to judge those of you who do choose to give charitably on a less regular or even automated basis, but to highlight the practice of giving and to illuminate one way among many that generosity, altruism and giving—all practices of dana—can be something that each of us can develop as a skill. 

Practice changing your frame of mind from one of getting to giving. Practice recognizing that you do have more to share than you might think. Practice creating routines of generosity. And in that practice, you might just find a new way to grow.

Subscribe to Yoga for Healthy Aging by Email ° Follow Yoga for Healthy Aging on Facebook and Twitter ° To order Yoga for Healthy Aging: A Guide to Lifelong Well-Being, go to Amazon, Shambhala, Indie Bound or your local bookstore.

Follow Victor Dubin on Facebook and @victordubin on Instagram, see Victor’s upcoming workshops and trainings, and view Victor’s online yoga class videos.

Friday, 20 July 2018

Victor Dubin Joins Yoga for Healthy Aging

by Nina
I first “met” Victor Dubin when I put the call out for stories about people whose lives had been changed by yoga, so I could use the stories in our book Yoga for Healthy Aging: A Guide to Lifelong Well-Being. Victor wrote in with an irresistible offer to write about how he had used yoga to lower his high blood pressure. Of course, I went for it, and I absolutely loved what he wrote for us (see Low-Pressure Tactics: Using Yoga to Lower Blood Pressure) because not only was it a very powerful story about yoga but it was very well written! And eventually I made his story the centerpiece of our chapter on heart and cardiovascular health. After that, to be honest, I didn’t think much about him until we had our first book party in early December of 2017 in Oakland, when a man walked up to me and announced to me that he was Victor Dubin and that he had driven all the way up from Santa Cruz to attend our book party! I was so happy to see him there and to meet him in person, all I could say was, “Victor!” But I did make a point of including his story in our presentation that night. 

After our presentation, we did have more time to talk and when Victor said he thought we thought do a book signing in Santa Cruz, we ended up making arrangements for Brad and me to do a book signing and Q&A at Nourish, the wellness center Victor co-founded with his wife, Jocelyn. So, a couple of months later, I only got to see Victor again, but I got to meet his wife, Jocelyn, and their daughter and see the wonderful Nourish Wellness Center and to have more time to chat and get to know each other better. Just before I left and Victor broached the idea of maybe doing more writing for the blog. Wow, I just jumped at the chance—hope I didn’t scare him! That’s because I knew that Victor is not only a long-time yoga teacher and yoga therapist, but he is also an excellent writer. Over the years, I’ve learned that this particular combination of skills is quite unusual. So, I started by giving him a trial period (which is what I normally do for writers who want to join the staff). Here is what he wrote during that time: 




Steady as She Goes: Forebearance and Steadfastness 

Now I’m pleased to announce that I’ve invited Victor to become a staff member! That means you’ll be hearing from him regularly now, at least once a month. And from now on, he’ll write under the name “Victor” and be listed on our About Us page. He will also have a page Victor’s Classes and Workshops Victor's Classes and Workshops with information his classes, workshops, and trainings.

Now here’s a bit about Victor. He is an Experienced Registered Yoga Teacher (ERYT 500) with Yoga Alliance and is also a member of the International Association of Yoga Therapists. He has been a full-time yoga teacher since 1996 and has taught more than 10,000 yoga classes. He describes his style of yoga as “non-dogmatic and non-denominational’ and says that yoga teaching “is not about attempting to fit people into particular models of practice, but rather is about creating space for people to discover themselves.” He develops and teaches classes in anatomy, physiology, in-depth posture exploration, meditation, philosophy, and history. 

In addition to regular yoga classes, Victor also leads Yoga Alliance Certified 200 and 500 Hour yoga teacher training programs in Santa Cruz and teaches yoga philosophy, research, and posture modification trainings for the ViraVinyasa teacher training program in Tulsa, OK. When it comes to his teaching style, many students respond positively to Victor’s ability to combine taking his work seriously while not taking himself too seriously. 

Victor is also the co-founder of NOURISH, a wellness center in Santa Cruz, CA with his wife, Registered Dietitian Jocelyn Dubin, MS RD, which is wear Victor teaches his yoga classes. 

In addition to teaching yoga, Victor has also been a track & field, cross country, and basketball coach for middle and high school. He is also a stand-up comedian and has performed at clubs in New York, Los Angeles and around the Bay Area. He lives with his wife, Jocelyn, and their daughter in Santa Cruz, CA. 

I personally am looking forward to reading the rest of his series on yamas and niyamas that are new to us but, uh, now that I learned he’s also a comedian, I hoping he’ll write something funny for us one of these days.


Subscribe to Yoga for Healthy Aging by Email ° Follow Yoga for Healthy Aging on Facebook and Twitter ° To order Yoga for Healthy Aging: A Guide to Lifelong Well-Being, go to AmazonShambhalaIndie Bound or your local bookstore.

For information about Nina's upcoming book signings and other activities, see Nina's Workshops, Book Signings, and Books.



Thursday, 19 July 2018

Steady as She Goes: Practicing Forbearance and Steadfastness

by Victor
Landscape with Windswept Trees by Vincent Van Gogh
Take a seat. Do your best to make the seat as comfortable as possible. Now, notice that no matter how comfortable the seat is, at some point you will have an inclination to get up from that seat. Some urge will strike you to get up and do something else or go somewhere else. And why shouldn’t you? You are free to “make that choice”. Or are you? Where did this urge come from? Why are you having it now? What is this other more important activity? To be clear, if this urge to get up from your seat comes from the fact that you are smelling smoke and there could be a potentially life threatening fire, then by all means listen to that urge. Or, if the urge comes from an awareness that sitting as you are will cause you or others harm in any way, then definitely heed the urge. Knowing what the source is of this inclination to do something else or be somewhere else is the point. 

Understanding why you are feeling some way is a practice of self awareness that can be cultivated. In most circumstances you will likely find that your desire to move or do or be somewhere other than where you are now is not rooted in legitimate, rational concern for life and limb, but rather there is some other non-life threatening discomfort that is being avoided, such as an uncomfortable thought or a feeling. And if you are like most people, then facing your own uncomfortable thoughts and feelings can be a challenge. When you sit with this challenge—when you face this discomfort—you are practicing the yoga yamas kshama (forbearance) and dhriti (steadfastness). 

The Shandilya Upanishad desrcibes kshama as “the bearing patiently of all pleasant or unpleasant things, such as praise or [a] blow” and dhriti as “the preserving of firmness of mind during period of gain or loss of wealth or of relatives.” The Yoga Yajnavalkya explains that kshama is “equality towards all things, favorable or unfavorable” and “…steadiness of mind in all situations is dhriti.” 

The assertion that I continue to make and concept that I continue to teach is that yamas are practices. The ability to be mentally, emotionally, and physically steady and steadfast is not an inherent trait for most of us, but it can be learned, practiced, and developed. Few people, if anyone, are “naturally” able to sit without feeling the inclination described above. However, many people have learned to pay closer attention to that inclination, to trace it to its root, to let it go, and be more at peace right where they are. These developing abilities are forbearance and steadfastness. 

While you can practice developing endurance and steadiness of mind in a practice of meditation, you can also build these skills in asana. Often practitioners of yoga postures approach the practice with a desired outcome in mind. As examples, for some this outcome is the achievement of a particular feat of strength or flexibility (the performance of the posture) and for others it might be the mitigation of some discomfort or pain. While you may achieve a particular position or alleviate a discomfort in a practice of yoga postures, you also may not. Even if you are successful sometimes, inevitably, sometimes you will also fail to reach these goals. If your sense of peace is wrapped up in the external physical achievement then sometimes—if not most times—you will be left without the sense of calm peacefulness that is at the core of yoga practice. If, instead, you practice accepting failure and achievement equally you will get better and better at finding a sense of peaceful calm regardless of outcomes. 

Like all yamas, kshama and dhriti need not only be practiced during a formal meditation or yoga posture practice. The clearest examples of this are in the social movements that have used non-violence as tools of change. The people who bore the oppressive blows of battery and imprisonment in the movement for liberation from colonial rule in India lead by Mohandas Gandhi were strong practitioners of kshama and dhriti. They were not born with these skills of forbearance and steadfastness, but practiced them and forged them in battles for independence. Similarly, during the U.S. Civil Rights Movement, the people who endured the blows of brutality while peacefully sitting in and standing up for justice did not just happen upon those moments. The organizations, like the Southern Christian Leadership Conference and Student Non-Violent Coordinating Committee, who led this movement, also led trainings where anyone could come and learn how to be steadfast, patient, and strong while also being peaceful and calm. 

You can practice being more patient everywhere and anywhere. Practice watching your inclinations to avoid non-harmful discomfort. Practice contemplating actions rather than engaging in knee-jerk reactions, first with simple things, such as getting up from your seat, then with more complex things, such as responding emotionally in conversation. As with most things, it will be difficult at first, but you’ll find that the more you practice the more skilled you will become at patiently enduring the good and the bad with steadiness of mind. 


Subscribe to Yoga for Healthy Aging by Email ° Follow Yoga for Healthy Aging on Facebook and Twitter ° To order Yoga for Healthy Aging: A Guide to Lifelong Well-Being, go to AmazonShambhalaIndie Bound or your local bookstore.

Follow Victor Dubin on Facebook and @victordubin on Instagram, see Victor’s upcoming workshops and trainings, and view Victor’s online yoga class videos.

Wednesday, 6 June 2018

Arjava: Integrating Integrity

by Victor Dubin
The Ancient of Days by William Blake
The yama arjava is sometimes translated as rectitude and is also translated as integrity. To me, integrity seems a more accessible and less severe term for a yama that can we can practice. I originally learned of arjava in Georg Feurstein’s Encyclopedic Dictionary of Yoga in his discussion of yamas: 

"...the Tri-Shikhi-Brahmana-Upanishad (II.32) mentions the following: non-harming, truthfulness, nonstealing, chastity, sympathy (daya), rectitude (arjava), patience (kshama), steadfastness (dhriti), moderate diet (mita-ahara), and cleanliness (shauca). This series is repeated in several other Yoga-Upanishads." 


The idea of expanding the field of yama and niyama practice appealed to my sense of the broader ethical implications of a practice of yoga and, particularly, a practice dedicated to integrity.

In my opinion, integrity is essential to all practitioners of yoga because it creates a foundation of deep honesty upon which a practice can best be built. It is a cornerstone of any practice of yoga, whether it includes postures, breathing, meditation, or any other yoga practices. Your integrity is expressed in the way that you, as one who practices yoga, honor your commitments to yourself, take time to be considerate of your actions, and represent your practice outwardly.

When you make a commitment to practice, each time you honor that commitment you are practicing arjava. Instead of practicing “when you feel like it,” I recommend setting a schedule and sticking to it. Feel free to put a sunset on the schedule (I like to set mine in 6 month increments, but you can choose a longer or shorter term if that is what works for you) so that you can reevaluate how things are going and if changes need to be made so that you can better meet your intentions with integrity.

This commitment to practice need not be rigid. In fact it will have more integrity if you are more honest about your needs in the moment. In other words, while you are broadly setting a schedule to which you are dedicated, what you do within the confines of that dedication need not be a rote routine.

Let’s say you decide that you are going to practice yoga postures for 20 minutes every Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday. You have a set of postures you enjoy or have learned that you plan to do and then you actually do this for several weeks regularly. If 7 or 8 weeks down the road you sprain an ankle tripping on the sidewalk, you have still made a commitment to practice. But in order to honor your commitment and practice arjava, there is no need to do the exact same postures that you were doing before the injury. In fact, still practicing, but modifying your practice to best support your health is a definition of integrity. This can be applied to your practice on a day-to-day and moment-to-moment basis as well. Showing up for the practice is the practice. Honoring the needs of the moment to best reduce suffering and promote healing is the practice.

You will likely find that the integrity with which you engage in your practice of yoga or applied to other parts of your life will have an effect beyond you and your mat. Like my daughter and her school, others are always affected by your actions.

Integrity is also relevant to yoga teachers. Little undermines the legitimacy of a teaching than a teacher who says one thing, but does another. T.K.V. Desikachar wrote in his book Health, Healing and Beyond, “A teacher of Yoga should live a life of Yoga – to practice what is taught.” In essence, if you are a teacher be mindful of what you say and do in and out of the classroom, be conscious of the expectations you place on others, and be attentive to the way that your words reflect your actions.

Finally, integrity is pertinent to the administration of yoga studios. Yoga studios and studio owners would be well advised to have clear communication regarding expectations of teachers and students. Written policies and practices are best, but even verbal communication is preferred to a total lack of clarity when it comes to things like how and when people pay, expiration dates, teaching ethics, teacher changes, class cancellations, and a host of other issues that arise at yoga studios.

When I was preparing to write this piece I asked my 14-year old daughter, “What are your thoughts on integrity?” She replied, “It just makes me mad.” Her response surprised me so I asked, “Why?” She told me that “integrity” is one of what her middle school calls “essentials”, a school-wide principle that she has been made to hear about over the past few years. Then our conversation ended abruptly, as is not unusual for a conversation with a teenager, and she was off to another activity.

I took time to consider why she might feel this way and it was pretty clear that what makes her mad is not that integrity is an espoused value of her school, but that it is not being practiced. In her experience teachers are very often not living up to their word and/or responsibilities and the administration has abdicated some of its responsibilities to students. As a specific example, a few months ago when students across the United States walked out of classes as a peaceful protest against gun violence in schools, her school took no proactive position. To be clear, she would have been upset if the school administration stood in opposition to student protest, but she would not have been frustrated with a lack of clarity. What the administration did in this case was to take no position on the health and welfare of students who attend the school, and in my daughter’s eyes this was not in alignment with the principle of integrity that the school claims to promote.

Yoga teachers often talk about and practitioners often give consideration to the idea of “alignment.” The alignment we most often examine is a physical one, the relationships of muscles, bones, and other physical structures to one another. These are worthy considerations that I support. But I further suggest we take more of our yoga practice time and time in our lives in general to evaluate the alignment of our stated goals with our actions and espoused principles with our practices. In this way we will practice and likely become more skilled at arjava and find the peace that flows from practicing and living with integrity.


Victor Dubin, ERYT 500 has been teaching yoga in Santa Cruz, California since 1996. He is a teacher at and co-owner of the wellness center NOURISH. Victor believes that "yoga is not about attempting to fit people into particular models of practice, but creating space for people to discover themselves."

Victor is the director of and primary yoga instructor for the NOURISH Yoga Teacher Training Program. He develops and teaches classes in anatomy, physiology, in-depth posture exploration, meditation, philosophy, and history. He also teaches How to Teach Yoga and guides student teachers in the art and science of class development and instruction. Victor teaches for the ViraVinyasa Yoga Teacher Training in Tulsa, OK and other workshops.

Class Schedule at mindbodyonline.com
Upcoming Workshops at mindbodyonline.com
Facebook: victordubin
Instagram: @victordubin

Subscribe to Yoga for Healthy Aging by Email ° Follow Yoga for Healthy Aging on Facebook and Twitter ° To order Yoga for Healthy Aging: A Guide to Lifelong Well-Being, go to AmazonShambhalaIndie Bound or your local bookstore.